Article Sidebar

Download
PDF
Statistic
Read Counter : 330 Download : 457

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Main Article Content

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to identify problems and alternative solutions in design of machine elements learning, in order to be used as a guide to development of learning model in the future. This literature review is conducted through searching journal within the scope of machine design learning with google scholar, www.springer.com, www.elsevier.com, www.sagepub.com and international conference proceedings resources. By searching keywords: machine design, machine design learning, teaching and learning of machine design, mechanical design, machine elements, obtained 100 journals and related proceedings, which selected into 79 journals and proceedings that describe the problems and alternative solutions according to the topic of this article. The results of the study shown the main problems in design of machine elements learning is: the learning still apply the traditional method, the sudject materials is not relevant to the field needs, the students do not have sufficient initial knowledge and experience, the lecturers lack experience guiding students to practice, lack of student English skills, the lack of practical exposure of students, and no validated framework for designing instructional development in changing traditional models of instructional design. Furthermore the alternative solutions offered are: make students learn actively and advance the concrete working mode, the course material is directed to design complex system through project engineering program, develop the model of 'joint experiment' study which discuss field problem, design activities done in the laboratory to apply classroom learning into a real world or apply the virtual laboratory modules or interactive laboratory simulations, and learning is done with a team-based hands-on approach, which provides students with practical experience in designing, fabricating and testing the strength and efficient mechanical systems.

Keywords

machine design traditional learning machine element learning hands-on technique virtual laboratory

Article Details

How to Cite
Septe, E., & Jalinus, N. (2019). Masalah dan Solusi Alternatif Pembelajaran Perancangan Elemen Mesin. INVOTEK: Jurnal Inovasi Vokasional Dan Teknologi, 19(1), 83-94. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.24036/invotek.v19i1.252

References

  1. [1]Ambrose. S.A and Amon. C.H, 1997, Systematic Design of a First-Year Mechanical Engineering Course at Carnegie Mellon University, Journal of Engineering Education, pp 173-181.
  2. [2]Jiang. H and Yen. C.C, 2013, Design Thinking in Conceptual Design Processes: A Comparison Between Industrial and Engineering Design Students, Advances in Industrial Design Engineering, http://dx.doi.org/10.5772/52460
  3. [3]Jirásko. J, Raab. Z dan Klepácek. J, 2015, E-learning study materials focused on projects from industry, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 176 ( 2015 ) 722–729
  4. [4]Katz. R, 2015, Integrating Analysis and Design in Mechanical Engineering Education, Procedia Conference Innovative Product Creation, 36 ( 2015 ) 23-28
  5. [5]Turner. D and Nagurka. M, 2014, Helicopters as a Theme in a Machine Design Course, Proceedings of the conference, 121st ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition, Atlanta, 2014, Paper ID #10409. American Society for Engineering Education, 2014
  6. [6]Mikhail. M and Engle. C.D, 2017, Enhancing Machine Design Course with an Integrated Vending Machine System, ASEE Paper ID #17760, American Society for Engineering Education, 2017
  7. [7]Li. H, Öchsner. A and Hall. W, 2017, Application of experiential learning to improve student engagement and experience in a mechanical engineering course, European Journal Of Engineering Education, 2017, Taylor and Francis
  8. [8]Tian. F, 2014, Improve Teaching Quality of Machine Design Course by Comprehensive Application of Multiple Meth, International Conference on Education Reform and Modern Management (ERMM 2014)
  9. [9]Stalford. H.L, 2014, Hands-On Method for Teaching Design of Mechanical Components Course, Proceedings of the conference, 121st ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition, Atlanta, 2014, American Society for Engineering Education, 2014
  10. [10]Sivaloganathan. S and Omar. F.K, 2016, Designing with Lessons from the Machine Design Course: A Capstone Experience, American Society for Engineering Education 123rd Annual Conference and Exposition Paper ID #15609, American Society for Engineering Education
  11. [11]Abumahaimed. M and Rencis. J.J, 2011, Mechanics of Materials, Machine Design, and Vibrations Finite Element Learning Modules for Undergraduate Courses, Proceedings Midwest Section Conference of the American Society for Engineering Education, Arkansas September 28-30, 2011.
  12. [12]Rompelman. O and De Graaff. E, 2006, The engineering of engineering education: curriculum development from a designer’s point of view, European Journal of Engineering Education, Vol. 31, No. 2, 2006, 215–226
  13. [13]Atman. C.J, Adams. R.S, Cardella, M.E, Turns. J, Mosborg.S and Saleem. J, 2007, Engineering Design Processes: A Comparison of Students and Expert Practitioners, Journal of Engineering Education, pp 359-379
  14. [14]Daly. S.R, Adams. R.S and Bodner. G.M, 2012, What Does it Mean to Design? A Qualitative Investigation of Design Professionals’ Experiences, Journal of Engineering Education, 2012, Vol. 101, No. 2, pp. 187–219
  15. [15]Monterrubio. L.E and Sirinterlikci. A, 2015, A Hands-on Approach in Teaching Machine Design, 122nd ASEE Annual Conference & Explotion, Seatle WA Paper ID #11528, American Society for Engineering Education, 2015
  16. [16]Dym. C.L, Agogino. A.M, Eris. E, Frey. D.D and Leifer. L.J, 2005, Engineering Design Thinking, Teaching, and Learning, Journal of Engineering Education, Vol 94, Issue 1, January 2005. P 103-120
  17. [17]Benedict. B.A, 2016, Studying Elements of Self-Paced Learning and Flipped Classroom to Enhance Course Design, Proceedings of International Conference on Engineering Education and Research, 21-24 Nov 2016, Western Sydney University, Parramatta Campus, Sydney, Australia
  18. [18]Sun. L, Chen. H, and Pang. S, 2017, Students’ Perception of Flipped Classroom Design in Engineering Courses , ASEE Southeast Section Conference, American Society for Engineering Education
  19. [19]Long. J.M, Pereira. M, and Chandrasekaran. S, 2017, Implementation of Project-Oriented Design-Based Learning in a Second-Year Mechanical/Mechatronics Subject, Proceedings, AAEE2017 Conference Manly, Sydney, Australia
  20. [20]Ahmed. A, Haque. M.M, Rahman. M.A and Rahman. A, 2016, Engineering Education in Bangladesh: Implementation of Online Delivery Approach, Proceedings of International Conference on Engineering Education and Research, 21-24 Nov 2016, Western Sydney University, Parramatta Campus, Sydney, Australia
  21. [21]Alemayehu. F.M, Logan. M.M and Barhorst. A, 2015, Development of a comprehensive assessment technique to invigorate students’ problem-solving skills and deter cheating, International Journal of Mechanical Engineering Education 2015, Vol. 43(4) 265–285
  22. [22]Chang. T.C, Tsai. Y.F, dan Wu. F.G, 2015, Interaction Design of Digital Teaching Improves Teaching and Learning Effectiveness, M. Antona and C. Stephanidis (Eds.): UAHCI 2015, Part III, LNCS 9177, pp. 15–22, 2015.DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-20684-4_2, Springer International Publishing Switzerland
  23. [23]Steuber. J.G, 2011, The Machine Component Design Manual Project and Other Tools for Teaching Mechanical Design, Proceedings of the Midwest Section Conference of the American Society for Engineering Education
  24. [24]Wood. J, Campbell. M, Wood. K and Jensen. D, 2005, Enhancing the teaching of machine design by creating a basic hands-on environment with mechanical ‘breadboards, International Journal of Mechanical Engineering Education 33/1 January 2005, SAGE Publications
  25. [25]Goh. Y.M,, McMahon. C.A, and Booker. J D, 2009, Improved utility and application of probabilistic methods for reliable mechanical design, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part O: Journal of Risk and Reliability, Vol. 223, pp 199-214, DOI: 10.1243/1748006XJRR244
  26. [26]Benne and Male. S.A, 2016, An Australian study of possible selves perceived by undergraduate engineering students, European Journal of Engineering Education, 2016, DOI: 10.1080/03043797.2016.1208149
  27. [27]Golenko.A, 2014, Zeszyty Naukowe Politechniki Śląskiej, Seria: Transport z. 83 Nr kol. 1904, 2014, Teaching Fundamentals of Machine Design In English
  28. [28]Sharma. G.V.S.S and Dumpala. R, 2015, Teaching of mechanical engineering concepts through three-dimensional geometric modeling, International Journal of Mechanical Engineering Education, 0(0) 1-11, SAGE Publisher, 2015..DOI: 10.1177/0306419015603013
  29. [29]Felder. R.M, Brent. R and Prince. M.J, 2011, Engineering Instructional Development:Programs, Best Practices, and Recommendations, Journal of Engineering Education, 100(1), 89 –122 (2011)
  30. [30]Felder. R.M, Woods. D.R, Stice. J.E and Rugarcia. A, 2000, The Future of Engineering Education : Teaching Methods That Work, Chemical Engineering Education, 34(1), 26–39 (2000)
  31. [31]Freuler. R.J, Fentiman. A.W, Demel. J.T, Gustafson. R.J and Merrill. J.A, Developing and Implementing Hands-on Laboratory Exercises and Design Projects for First Year Engineering Students, Proceedings of the 2001 American Society for Engineering Education Annual Conference & Exposition
  32. [32]Asunda. P.A and Hill. R.B, 2007, Critical Features of Engineering Design in Technology Education, Journal of Industrial Teacher Education, Vol. 44 Np.1, pp 25-36
  33. [33]Campbell. M.I and Schmidt. K.J, 2005, Incorporating Open-Ended Projects into a Machine Elements Course, Proceedings of the 2005 American Society for Engineering Education Annual Conference & Exposition Copyright © 2005, American Society for Engineering Education
  34. [34]Liem. A and Sigurjonsson. J.B, 2014, Positioning Industrial Design Education within Higher Education: How to face increasingly challenging market forces?, Uniped argang 37, 2/2014, side 44-57
  35. [35]Calabro. K.M, Kiger. K.T, Lawson. W and Zhang. G, 2008, New Directions in Freshman Engineering Design at the University of Maryland, 38th ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference
  36. [36]Dutson. A.J, Todd. R.H, Magleby. S.P and Sorensen. C.D, 1997, A Review of Literature on Teaching Engineering Design Through Project-Oriented Capstone Courses, Journal of Engineering Education, p 17-28
  37. [37]Raju. P.K, Sankar. C.S, Halpin. G and Glennelle. H, 2000, An Innovative Teaching Method to Improve Engineering Design Education, ASEE Conference paper No. 1093, St. Louis, MO, 2000
  38. [38]Covill. D, Katz. T and Morris. R, 2007, A Top Down Approach to Teaching Engineering Mechanics, International Symposium for Engineering Education, 2007, Dublin City University, Ireland
  39. [39]Hyman. B, 2003, Public Policy and Engineering Design Education, International Journal of Engineering Education. Vol. 19, No. 1, 2003, pp. 110-117
  40. [40]Canfield. S.L and Zuccaro. S.G, 2016, Digital homework for kinematics and dynamics of machinery, International Journal of Mechanical Engineering Education, 2016, Vol. 44(2) 165–182, DOI: 10.1177/0306419016641008
  41. [41]Soeiro. A and Falcão. R, 2013, Assessment of Student Learning Outcomes in Engineering Education and Impact in Teaching, International Conference on Engineering Education& International Conference on Information Technology, 2013
  42. [42]Hoit. M and Ohland. M, 1998, The Impact of a Discipline-Based Introduction to Engineering Course on Improving Retention, Journal of Engineering Education, American Society for Engineering Education, Vol.87 (1), January 1998, pp 79-85
  43. [43]Anderson. E.E and Hashemi. J, 2006, Virtual Laboratories: Changing Engineering Education, Paper 9th International Conference on Engineering Education July 23 – 28, 2006
  44. [44]McLaren. A, 2008, Approaches to the Teaching of Design an Engineering Subject Centre guide, Higher Education Academy Engineering Subject Centre
  45. [45]Farouki. R.T and Linke. B.S, 2016, Shigley Hauler—A competitive project illustrating basic machine design principles, International Journal of Mechanical Engineering Education 2016, Vol. 44(4) 284–301, SAGE Publisher, 2016.
  46. [46]Serdar. T, 2015, Project based learning in Manufacturing Processes Course, American Society for Engineering Education
  47. [47]Lemons. G, Carberry. A, Swan. C and Rogers. C, 2010, The Benefits of Model Building in Teaching Engineering Design, Design Studies Elsevier Ltd, 31 (2010) 288-309
  48. [48]Purwar. A, 2016, Enabling Machine Design Innovation among Freshman Mechanical Engineering Students, 123rd ASEE Annual Conference & Explotion, Mew Orleasn LA Paper ID #16469,American Society for Engineering Education, 2016
  49. [49]Coller. B.D and Scott. M.J, 2009, Effectiveness of Using a Video Game to Teach A Course in Mechanical Engineering, Computers & Education 53 (2009) 900–912
  50. [50]Galaup. M, Muller. N, Lelardeux. C.P, Panzoli. D, Jessel, J.P, Lagarrigue. P, 2017, Design of learning environments for Mechanical Engineering, Procedia Manufacturing 13 (2017) 1440–1446
  51. [51]Purzer. S, Goldstein. M.H, Adams. R.S, Xie. C and Nourian. S, 2015, An exploratory study of informed engineering design behaviors associated with scientific explanations, International Journal of STEM Education (2015) 2:9
  52. [52]Raucent. B, 2001, Introducing problem-based learning in a machine design curriculum: Result of an experiment, Journal of Engineering Design 12:4, 293-308
  53. [53]Agouridas. V and Race. P, 2007, Enhancing Knowledge Management in Design Education Through Systematic Reflection Practice, Concurrent Engineering: Research and Applications Volume 15 Number 1 March 2007
  54. [54]Prudhomme. G, Boujut. J.F.O and Brissaud. D, 2003, Toward Reflective Practice in Engineering Design Education, International Journal Engineering Education. Vol. 19, No. 2, pp. 328-337, 200
  55. [55]Oxman. R, 2004, Think-Maps: Teaching Design Thinking In Design Education, Design Studies 25 (2004) 63–91
  56. [56]Turns. J, Cardella. M, Atman. C.J, Martin. J, Newman. J and Adams. R.S, 2006, Tackling the Research-to-Teaching Challenge in Engineering Design Education: Making the Invisible Visible, International Journal of Engineering Education. Vol. 22, No. 3, pp. 598-608, 2006
  57. [57]McLaren, A.J. and Jenkins, P, 2010, Mechanical Dissection in An Introductory Engineering Design Module, 6th International CDIO Conference, 15-18 June 2010, Montréal, Canada
  58. [58]Yang. M.C and Epstein. D.J, 2005, A study of Prototypes, Design Activity, and Design Outcome, Design Studies 26 (2005) 649-669
  59. [59]Youssef. G and Arutyunov. V, 2013, An Approach to Integrate Systems Engineering into Senior Design, ASEE 123 Annual Conference and Exposition, New Orleans, LA, June 2016
  60. [60]Williams. B and Figueiredo. J, 2014, From Academia to Start-up: A Case Study with Implications for Engineering Education, International Journal of Educational Psychology Vol 4, Issue 1, 2014
  61. [61]Audet. J and Pegna. J, 2001, Engineering and Commerce Students Join Forces With a Corporate Sponsor, New Product Development Industry & Higher Education, August 2001, p 257-267
  62. [62]Aqqal. A, Elhannani. A, Haidine. A and Dahbi. A, 2017, Improving the Teaching of ICT Engineering Using Flipped Learning: A Personalized Model and A Case Study, Production, 27(spe), e20162274, 2017
  63. [63]Meyer. H, 2018, Teachers’ Thoughts on Student Decision Making During Engineering Design Lessons, Journal of Educaion Science, 2018, 8, 9
  64. [64]Nagurka. M, Anton. F.R, Marklin. R, Jr, 2013, Using Remote Access for Sharing Experiences in A Machine Design Laboratory, The World Engineering Education Forum, Asociación Colombiana de Facultades de Ingeniería (ACOFI), International Federation of Engineering Education Societies (IFEES)
  65. [65]Kanelopoulos. J, Papanikolaou. J dan Zalimidis. P, 2017, Flipping The Classroom to Increase Students’ Engagement and Interaction in a Mechanical Engineering Course on Machine Design, International Journal of Engineering Pedagogy Vol.7, No. 4
  66. [66]Kim. Y, 2015, Learning statics through in-class demonstration, assignment and evaluation, International Journal of Mechanical Engineering Education 0(0) 1–15
  67. [67]Blum. M.M and Dannenhoffer. J.F, 2017, Integrated use of Programming in Machine Design Course, ASEE Paper ID #18448 c American Society for Engineering Education, 2017
  68. [68]Ćwikła. G, 2013, Interactive 3D Presentation as A Tool in Learning of The Technological Processes Design, Selected Engineering Problems No.4, Institut of Engineering Process Automation and Integrated Manufacturing System
  69. [69]Li. X, Wei. J, Ding. S and Wang. Q, 2017, Teaching Mode of Mechanical Design Course based on Simulation Analysis Technology, iJET ‒ Vol. 12, No. 7, 2017
  70. [70]Suraishkumar. G. K, 2017, Strategies to Improve Learning of All Students in A Class, European Journal of Engineering Education 2017
  71. [71]Green. G and Kennedy. P, 2001, Redefining Engineering Education: The reflective practice of Product Design Engineering, International Journal of Engineering Education 17(1) January 2001
  72. [72]Davies . H.C, 2013, Integrating a Multi-University Design Competition Into a Mechanical Engineering Design Curriculum Using Modern Design Pedagogy, Journal of Engineering Design, 2013, Vol. 24, No. 5, 383–396
  73. [73]Fatmadilla. D, Usmeldi dan Krismadinata, Penerapan Strategi Training Within Industry Dalam Pembelajaran Mengoperasikan Sistem Pengendali Elektromagnetik, Jurnal Inovasi, Vokasional dan Teknologi, Vol. 17 No. 2, Oktober 2017
  74. [74]Anderson. K.J.B, Courter. S.S, McGlamery. T, Kelly. T.M.N and Nicometo. C.C, 2010, Understanding Engineering Work and Identity: A Cross-Case Analysis of Engineers Within Six Firms, Engineering Studies Vol. 2, No. 3, December 2010, 153–174
  75. [75]Baronos. A, 2016, Education For Sustainability- Experiences From Greece, IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 161 (2016) 012103 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/161/1/012103
  76. [76]Saha. S. K, 2006, Design for effective Teaching and Learning in Technical Education, National Conference on Design for Product Life, 17-18 Feb 2006
  77. [77]Clark. R.M, Mary. B.S, Dlbudny, Karen M.B, Clark. W.W,Norman. B.A, Parker. R.S, Patzer. J.F and Slaughter. W.S, 2017, Flipping Engineering Courses: A School Wide Initiative, Advances in Engineering Education
  78. [78]Sherry H and Agogino. A.M, 1995, Scaffolding Knowledge Integration through Designing Multimedia Case Studies of Engineering Design, Frontiers in Education Conference 4dl.
  79. [79]Cohen. K and Katz. R, 2015, Teaching Mechanical Design Practice in Academia, Procedia CIRP 36 (2015) 177 – 181